Contact Our Experts for Global Halal Certification Inquiries
SOP-14-ALL-EN Rev. 001/2023 29 January 2023

Handling and evaluation of complaints/ appeals (SOP)

Handling and evaluation of complaints, appeals and review requests

IHC procedure (SOP-14) describing how complaints, appeals against certification decisions, and requests to review evaluation decisions are handled.

This procedure aims at describing the steps adopted by IHC for:

  • Complaints handling
  • Handling of appeal against a certification decision
  • Handling of request of reviewing an evaluation decision

This SOP applies to all parties that are involved in the complaints, appeals, and review request procedure. All IHC clients have the right to make a complaint, appeal against any certification decision or request a review of any evaluation IHC may take if they can bring forward good arguments. This SOP outlines the principles and responsibilities with regards to complaints, appeals and review requests.

It’s the responsibility of the QM, TD and CAC to ensure the proper setting, implementation, and communication of this document.

GM General management
IC Impartiality committee
SC Sharia committee
CDC Certification decision committee
CAC Complaints / Appeals committee
BSD Business & sales development
MA Management assistance
TD Technical department
OM Operation management
QM Quality management
AD Administration
HR Human resources
AC Accounting department
CCS Customer & consumer service
BO Branch office
ACT Auditing and certification team
AR Application reviewer
TA Technical auditor
IAE Islamic affairs expert
TE Technical expert
LA Lead auditor
SU Supervisor (meat)
CR Certification reviewer
QMS Quality management system
IHC International Halal Center
CB Certification body
HCB Halal certification body
AB Accreditation body
SOP Standard operating procedure
PFC Process flow chart
NC Non-conformity
COC Certificate of conformity

Certification Scheme: The certification system related to specified products, to which the same specified requirements, specific rules and procedures apply.

Product certification: A third-party attestation related to products.

Complaint

An expression of dissatisfaction by individual(s) or organization(s) (including certified organization(s)) with an issue related to IHC or organizations certified by IHC in writing. Specifically, the complaint is related to the certification service of IHC.

Certification decision

A decision taken by IHC to grant or deny initial certification, confirm certification after surveillance audit, renew certification, extend a certificate, suspend a certificate, lift the suspension or to decertify. A certification decision becomes valid with immediate effect.

Evaluation decision

A decision taken by IHC to confirm non-conformities identified during an audit, confirm corrective measure proposals or objective evidence, verify objective evidence during a follow-up audit without suspension, or to consider a major non-conformity. An evaluation decision becomes valid with immediate effect.

Appeal

A request to review and reverse a certification decision. Appeals against certification decisions are decided on by the CAC of IHC.

Requests for review

Requests to review an evaluation decision and are handled by the TD.

Complaints/appeals committee (CAC)

An internal quality control body that objectively handles complaints considering any raised argument and objection by the involved parties. As a company-internal body, its role is not that of an external or official arbitration body nor a court-like institution.

  1. Complaints, appeals, and requests of review must be submitted through written text. The client feedback form of IHC (FOR-15) can be used for complaints. They can also be sent via email, fax, filling an online form, or other means to transfer written texts.
  2. A complaint related to IHC certification service can be submitted any time.
  3. A review request against an evaluation decision can be submitted within 1 month after an evaluation decision is taken.
  4. An appeal can be submitted within 1 month after a certification decision.
  5. IHC will not respond to anonymous requests without clear contact information.
  6. After receipt in writing, IHC shall investigate whether it relates to the certification activities of IHC.
  7. IHC confirms the receipt and acknowledgement to the complainant, review-request submitter, or appellant using an official letter.
  8. The QM maintains a log of complaints, appeals or request of reviews (LIS-02).
  9. The QM shall handle or forward the complaints, appeals, and requests of review. After initial evaluation, the QM decides if the request stays with QM or is forwarded to the TD or to the CAC.
  10. The present status of evaluation or certification stays unaffected until a revised decision is issued. The new decision is valid with immediate effect.
  11. Interested parties or ABs can ask to see and evaluate the log of complaints, appeals or request of reviews.
  • Against QMS of IHC (complaint)
  • Against implementation of the QMS of IHC (complaint)
  • Against IHC-certified product or client (complaint)
  • General dissatisfaction against the whole IHC or personnel of IHC
  • Against already taken evaluation decisions (request of review)
  • Against already taken certification decisions (appeal)

All complaints, appeals, and review requests must state the reason(s) and need to be supported by information and evidence. This is important for the IHC case evaluation. They may have one or more of the following reasons:

  • Confidentiality not held
  • Bias or unfair behavior or decision
  • Failure to consider presented and relevant information
  • Unreasonable delay in processing or taking decision
  • Unprofessional behavior or decision
  • Dispute about facts
  • Other reasons mentioned by complainant, appellant, and request provider

This procedure is handled by the QM, TD or CAC and includes the following steps:

1 Gathering more relevant information
2 Discussion with other related parties
3 Analysis of the cause(s)
4 Internal discussion
5 Decision
6 Reply to the complainant, appellant, or request provider
7 Proposal of corrective action
8 Proposal of preventive actions

The committee involves the following personnel:

QM

Quality department (QM) — 1 person

TD

Technical department (TD) — 1 person

SC

Sharia committee (SC) — 1 person

The decision is taken upon unanimity (3-0) or majority (2-1).

The flow chart of this process is shown in PFC-14.

PFC-14
Submitter Complainant Complaint Appellant Appeal Review request submitter Review request Receipt confirmation (acknowledgement) Initial evaluation Further investigation? No Yes Final evaluation Documentation: log Decision Corrective and preventive actions Closing Reply Confirmation letter Decision letter
  • List of complaints, appeals and review requests (List)
  • Organizational chart (Chart)
  • Functions, responsibilities, and authorities of personnel (SOP)
  • Certification scheme (SOP)
  • Decision making procedure (SOP)
  • Company official letter (Form)
  • KPIs (SOP)
  • Quality policy
  • Confidentiality measures (SOP)
  • Evaluation, monitoring, and management of personnel qualification (SOP)

Need to submit a complaint or appeal?

Use the online form on the Complaints page. The Complaints and Appeals Committee will respond within three weeks.

Go to Complaints form